C-Store Manager Success: Michelle Cornwell’s Formula for Growth

September 10, 2025

In the fast-moving world of convenience stores, achieving c-store manager success goes beyond tracking sales or keeping shelves stocked. It’s about creating a store culture where employees feel motivated, customers feel valued, and every day brings opportunities for growth.

This blog highlights how Michelle Cornwell has mastered this balance. From spotting future leaders and boosting team morale to creating a customer-focused food program, Michelle’s strategies provide a roadmap for managers looking to drive results, build strong teams, and make their stores a destination in the community.

C-Store Manager Success Starts with Spotting Leaders

For Michelle, identifying a future leader is simple: it starts with initiative.

“I look for somebody who steps in without being told, understands what needs to be done, and naturally guides others in the right direction.”

For her, leadership isn’t about perfection. In fact, a team member may struggle with punctuality or have an off day with their attitude, but that doesn’t erase their potential. No one begins as the perfect candidate. What matters most is character and consistency.

That’s why Michelle spends time learning about her team’s goals and values. True leadership reveals itself over time, not in a single shift.

Why Positivity Pays Off

Step into Michelle’s store and you feel it right away: smiles from the team, warm greetings for customers, and an energy that makes the place feel welcoming. “If your team isn’t happy, customers notice the moment they walk in,” Michelle says.

She makes morale a priority from the start of every shift. A quick hello or a lighthearted joke sets the tone and when someone walks in upset, Michelle has a go-to move: “I’ll tell them, ‘If there’s anything we can do to make you smile today, you let us know and we’ll keep trying until it happens.” More often than not, frustration turns into laughter and casual visitors turn into loyal regulars.

Creating a Food Program That Feels Like a Destination

A shiny new kitchen doesn’t guarantee success. Instead, Michelle’s food program thrives because it reflects the needs of her community.

“We look at the type of customers we serve. In our area, there are a lot of construction workers and busy people on the move, so we focus on hearty, filling meals that are easy to carry with them.”

One surprise hit has been sausage gravy and biscuits, which quickly became an all-day bestseller.

To keep things fresh, Michelle also runs daily themed specials:

Monday – Smash burgers
Tuesday – Taco Tuesday
Wednesday – BBQ beef sandwiches
Thursday – Manager’s special
Friday – Customer favorite: big fried chicken

However, flexibility is part of the fun. “We don’t just make those items on their set days. If a customer asks for smash burgers on a Wednesday, of course we’ll make them. What matters is listening and making people feel heard. I even have one customer who pulls me out of the office just to make her favorite meal, and I do it. That’s how you build loyalty and turn casual visitors into repeat customers.”

C-Store Manager Success: Increasing Sales Through Food and Community

Success in convenience stores doesn’t happen by accident, it comes from smart leadership and strong connections to the community. Michelle, a record-setting manager, credits her growth in daily sales to knowing her customers and creating reasons for them to return.

She explained, “We have the White River Amphitheatre nearby with concerts every summer, that’s really big for us. This year I started doing raffles with our products, which helped with upselling. We also have businesses in the area that come just to eat our food. We’ve built a really good reputation with our food and the variety we offer.”

Her message is clear: lean into challenges, learn from failures, and keep moving forward.

Michelle’s Final Word: Learn Through the Struggle

When asked what advice she would give to someone starting out as a c-store manager, Michelle said,

“Even when you’re having a hard time, don’t give up, keep going. In the long run, the mistakes you make are lessons that make you stronger and better.”

Her resilience, paired with a belief in people, sets her apart. Michelle doesn’t just hit sales targets, she creates leaders, inspires loyalty, and turns her store into something much bigger than a place to shop. In retail, the biggest asset isn’t the product on the shelf. Instead, it’s the team that brings it to life.

Blog